However, this infuriates Mommy Long Legs in the process, who starts hunting down The Player, claiming that The Player 'cheated', and that she is going to play 'one last game' with us, calling it 'hide-and-seek'. The Player escapes the third game, which is obviously rigged (the ending is blocked by debris). The Player stops when the lights turn on and can move when the lights go off. Green Light’, where The Player navigates a maze while being pursued by PJ Pug-a-Pillar. The third game is Statues, a game similar to ‘Red Light. The second game is Wack-a-Wuggy, a game similar to 'Whack-a-Mole', where The Player must hit the Mini Huggies, which are small, differently colored Huggy Wuggy toys as they as it comes out of holes in the wall across various areas. The Player then finds themselves in a rejected toys warehouse, where there is a switch to unlock the door which leads to the train station.

This will gradually get faster until the game malfunctions and an emergency stop is required. The first game is Musical Memory, a 'Simon Says'-like game where The Player has to select the correct buttons. Once in the station, Mommy Long Legs confronts The Player, stating that in order to escape, The Player must play three games that become increasingly more difficult. This plan is soon vandalized, as the chapter's main antagonist, Mommy Long Legs assaults and snatches Poppy, forcing The Player to drop down to attempt to save her. After the event of Chapter 1: A Tight Squeeze, The Player follows Poppy, who, in response to the player's rescue, decides to help The Player escape via the Game Station located deep under the facility.

It takes two playtime